Chief Justice br Gavai
- Rakesh Kishore approached the dais on the raised platform, removed his shoe, and attempted to throw it towards the judges, including Chief Justice of India (CJI) Justice BR Gavai. Security personnel quickly intervened and foiled the attempt.(ANI)
- A day after attempting to hurl a shoe at Chief Justice of India (CJI) Justice BR Gavai inside the Supreme Court, 71-year-old lawyer Rakesh Kishore on Tuesday defended his actions, saying he was “deeply hurt” by the CJI’s remarks during a previous hearing related to a religious matter. The Bar Council of India has suspended Kishore’s licence with immediate effect.
Chief Justice br Gavai
- he dramatic incident took place on Monday during the mentioning of cases before a CJI-led bench. According to witnesses, Rakesh Kishore suddenly approached the dais on the raised platform, removed his shoe, and attempted to throw it towards the judges. Security personnel quickly intervened and foiled the attempt.
Chief Justice br Gavai
- Speaking to news agency ANI, Kishore said, “The CJI should think that when he is sitting on such a high constitutional post, he should understand the meaning of ‘Milord’ and uphold its dignity. You go to Mauritius and say that the country will not run with a bulldozer. I ask the CJI and those opposing me: Is the bulldozer action by Yogi (Adityanath) ji against those who encroached on government property wrong? I am hurt and will continue to be so.”
Chief Justice br Gavai
- Speaking at the Sir Maurice Rault Memorial Lecture 2025 in Mauritius on the “Rule of Law in the Largest Democracy,” Justice BR Gavai earlier this month reaffirmed that India’s legal system is guided by the rule of law, not the “rule of the bulldozer”. Gavai cited his own verdict that denounced “bulldozer justice.”
- In November 2024, the ruling held that such actions bypass due process, violate the rule of law, and infringe the fundamental right to shelter under Article 21. “The executive cannot assume the roles of judge, jury, and executioner simultaneously,” recalled the CJI, highlighting how the judgment laid down guidelines to ensure no demolition could take place without following the due procedure of law.
Justifying his act in the courtroom, Kishore claimed it was a reaction to what he called “mockery” of a public interest litigation (PIL) filed on September 16.
“I was deeply hurt. On September 16, a PIL (public interest litigation) was filed by an individual in the chief justice’s court. Justice Gavai completely mocked it. Mockery in the sense that he said, ‘Go pray to the idol, ask the idol to restore its own head’,” Kishore said.
- He alleged that the judiciary acts differently in cases involving other communities. “We see that the same chief justice takes big steps when a case comes up against other communities… Let me give an example: In Haldwani, railway land is encroached upon by a specific community. When attempts were made to remove the encroachment, the Supreme Court imposed a stay three years ago, which is still in effect today. Similarly, when the Nupur Sharma case came up, the court said, ‘You have spoiled the atmosphere’. They do all that. That is perfectly fine,” he said.
Chief Justice br Gavai
- Kishore said he felt disheartened by the court’s approach towards issues related to Sanatan Dharma, citing examples such as Jallikattu and Dahi Handi. “Whenever an issue related to our Sanatan Dharma comes up, this Supreme Court continues to pass some kind of order regarding it. I am very sad that they should not be doing this,” he said.
- Chief Justice br Gavai
- The lawyer claimed his actions were not driven by intoxication or impulse, but by “emotional distress”. “It’s not like I was drunk, or I had taken any pills, and then came and did something. Nothing like that happened. They took action. It was my reaction,” he said, adding that he neither fears nor regrets what happened.
“Although I am strongly against violence, you must also consider why a non-violent, simple, honest person, who has no case against him till date and doesn’t belong to any group, had to do all this? This is certainly something worth thinking about. The whole country should reflect on what happened,” Kishore said.
Chief Justice br Gavai
-
Kishore, who claims to hold an MSc, PhD, and LLB degree and is a gold medalist, reiterated that he stood by his act, stating, “I am free to say this: I am not fearful of anything. Nor do I regret what happened or what didn’t happen.”
- The lawyer added, “My name is Dr Rakesh Kishore. Can someone tell my caste? Maybe I am a Dalit too. It is one-sided that you are taking advantage of the fact that he (CJI Gavai) is a Dalit. He is not a Dalit. He was a Sanatani Hindu first. He then renounced his faith and followed Buddhism. If he feels that he has come out of Hinduism after following Buddhism, how is he still a Dalit? This is about mindset.”
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday strongly condemned the attack on the CJI and said it had “angered every Indian”. Chief Justice br Gavai
The prime minister spoke with Justice Gavai. He appreciated the calm displayed by the CJI and said it highlights his commitment to strengthening the spirit of our Constitution.
Chief Justice br Gavai
- “Spoke to Chief Justice of India, Justice BR Gavai Ji. The attack on him earlier today in the Supreme Court premises has angered every Indian. There is no place for such reprehensible acts in our society. It is utterly condemnable. I appreciated the calm displayed by Justice Gavai in the face of such a situation. It highlights his commitment to values of justice and strengthening the spirit of our Constitution,” Modi said in a post on X.
Several other leaders also strongly condemned the incident. The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) has issued a firm resolution condemning the conduct of the advocate who disrupted proceedings in the courtroom of the Chief Justice of India.
Chief Justice br Gavai
- he Chief Justice, who appeared unruffled, said nothing landed on him or his desk. “I only heard the sound. Maybe it fell on some table or somewhere,” he told this newspaper, adding, “I only heard him say ‘maine Gavai saab ke taraf pheka tha’. Perhaps what he threw landed somewhere else and he was trying to explain.” Chief Justice br Gavai
The man, identified later as Advocate Rakesh Kishore, was quickly escorted out by security personnel. “An advocate who was present inside the courtroom at the time said the man flung something at the CJI during mentioning hours. The ‘attacker’ then waited there for some seconds before being escorted out,” an eyewitness told The Indian Express.
Chief Justice br Gavai
- The lawyer, sources in the Delhi Police said, had attempted to throw his shoe at the CJI to protest the latter’s remarks during a recent hearing of a plea seeking restoration of a Lord Vishnu idol in the Khajuraho Temple complex in Madhya Pradesh.
Presiding over a Bench with Justice K Vinod Chandran, CJI Gavai had made the remarks on September 16 while dismissing a plea seeking the reconstruction of a dilapidated 7-foot-tall Lord Vishnu idol at the Javari Temple in Khajuraho.
“This purely publicity interest litigation… Go and ask the deity himself to do something. If you are saying that you are a strong devotee of Lord Vishnu, then you pray and do some meditation,” the CJI had told the petitioner.
Chief Justice br Gavai